Skills › Scientific Agent Skills › scientific-writing › reporting_guidelines.json
reporting_guidelines.json
529 lines · skills/scientific-writing/assets/reporting_guidelines.json at 5f2bc03
1{
2 "as_of": "2026-10-01",
3 "guidelines": [
4 {
5 "conditions": {},
6 "coverage_topics": [
7 {
8 "id": "design-and-randomization",
9 "label": "Trial design, allocation, concealment, and masking"
10 },
11 {
12 "id": "participants-and-flow",
13 "label": "Eligibility, recruitment, analysis populations, and participant flow"
14 },
15 {
16 "id": "outcomes-and-harms",
17 "label": "Prespecified outcomes, estimates, uncertainty, and harms"
18 },
19 {
20 "id": "registration-protocol-analysis-plan",
21 "label": "Registration, protocol, analysis plan, and deviations"
22 },
23 {
24 "id": "open-science-and-funding",
25 "label": "Data sharing, funding, conflicts, and contributor information"
26 }
27 ],
28 "id": "consort-2025",
29 "name": "CONSORT 2025",
30 "official_url": "https://www.consort-spirit.org/",
31 "protocol": false,
32 "role": "primary",
33 "source_ids": [
34 "SW-S07",
35 "SW-S08"
36 ],
37 "study_designs": [
38 "randomized_trial",
39 "pilot_randomized_trial"
40 ],
41 "version": "2025"
42 },
43 {
44 "conditions": {
45 "ai": true
46 },
47 "coverage_topics": [
48 {
49 "id": "ai-intervention-description",
50 "label": "AI intervention, inputs, outputs, version, and intended use"
51 },
52 {
53 "id": "human-ai-interaction",
54 "label": "Human oversight, user expertise, and interaction workflow"
55 },
56 {
57 "id": "error-analysis",
58 "label": "Performance errors, failure cases, and subgroup behavior"
59 }
60 ],
61 "id": "consort-ai-2020",
62 "name": "CONSORT-AI extension",
63 "official_url": "https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/consort-artificial-intelligence/",
64 "protocol": false,
65 "role": "extension",
66 "source_ids": [
67 "SW-S07",
68 "SW-S31"
69 ],
70 "study_designs": [
71 "randomized_trial",
72 "pilot_randomized_trial"
73 ],
74 "version": "2020"
75 },
76 {
77 "conditions": {},
78 "coverage_topics": [
79 {
80 "id": "administrative-information",
81 "label": "Registration, version, roles, funding, and governance"
82 },
83 {
84 "id": "design-and-interventions",
85 "label": "Trial design, interventions, allocation, and masking"
86 },
87 {
88 "id": "outcomes-and-analysis",
89 "label": "Outcomes, sample size, analysis plan, and missing data"
90 },
91 {
92 "id": "data-monitoring-and-harms",
93 "label": "Data management, monitoring, auditing, and harms"
94 },
95 {
96 "id": "ethics-dissemination-and-access",
97 "label": "Ethics, consent, confidentiality, dissemination, and access"
98 }
99 ],
100 "id": "spirit-2025",
101 "name": "SPIRIT 2025",
102 "official_url": "https://www.consort-spirit.org/",
103 "protocol": true,
104 "role": "primary",
105 "source_ids": [
106 "SW-S07",
107 "SW-S09"
108 ],
109 "study_designs": [
110 "randomized_trial",
111 "pilot_randomized_trial"
112 ],
113 "version": "2025"
114 },
115 {
116 "conditions": {
117 "ai": true
118 },
119 "coverage_topics": [
120 {
121 "id": "ai-intervention-versioning",
122 "label": "AI intervention version, updates, inputs, outputs, and workflow"
123 },
124 {
125 "id": "human-ai-protocol",
126 "label": "Human oversight, user expertise, and interaction protocol"
127 },
128 {
129 "id": "ai-error-monitoring",
130 "label": "Error handling, performance monitoring, and safety"
131 }
132 ],
133 "id": "spirit-ai-2020",
134 "name": "SPIRIT-AI extension",
135 "official_url": "https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/spirit-artificial-intelligence/",
136 "protocol": true,
137 "role": "extension",
138 "source_ids": [
139 "SW-S09",
140 "SW-S32"
141 ],
142 "study_designs": [
143 "randomized_trial",
144 "pilot_randomized_trial"
145 ],
146 "version": "2020"
147 },
148 {
149 "conditions": {},
150 "coverage_topics": [
151 {
152 "id": "eligibility-and-information-sources",
153 "label": "Eligibility criteria, information sources, and complete search strategy"
154 },
155 {
156 "id": "selection-and-data-collection",
157 "label": "Selection, extraction, data items, and reviewer processes"
158 },
159 {
160 "id": "bias-and-certainty",
161 "label": "Risk of bias, reporting bias, and certainty assessment"
162 },
163 {
164 "id": "synthesis-and-heterogeneity",
165 "label": "Effect measures, synthesis methods, heterogeneity, and sensitivity analyses"
166 },
167 {
168 "id": "registration-support-and-availability",
169 "label": "Registration, protocol, amendments, support, conflicts, data, and code"
170 }
171 ],
172 "id": "prisma-2020",
173 "name": "PRISMA 2020",
174 "official_url": "https://www.prisma-statement.org/prisma-2020",
175 "protocol": false,
176 "role": "primary",
177 "source_ids": [
178 "SW-S10"
179 ],
180 "study_designs": [
181 "systematic_review",
182 "meta_analysis"
183 ],
184 "version": "2020"
185 },
186 {
187 "conditions": {},
188 "coverage_topics": [
189 {
190 "id": "design-setting-and-participants",
191 "label": "Design, setting, dates, eligibility, selection, and follow-up"
192 },
193 {
194 "id": "variables-data-sources-and-bias",
195 "label": "Variables, measurement, data sources, and bias"
196 },
197 {
198 "id": "study-size-and-statistics",
199 "label": "Study size, quantitative variables, confounding, missing data, and sensitivity"
200 },
201 {
202 "id": "participants-outcomes-and-estimates",
203 "label": "Participant flow, descriptive data, outcomes, and adjusted estimates"
204 },
205 {
206 "id": "limitations-generalizability-and-funding",
207 "label": "Limitations, interpretation, generalizability, and funding"
208 }
209 ],
210 "id": "strobe-2007",
211 "name": "STROBE",
212 "official_url": "https://www.strobe-statement.org/checklists/",
213 "protocol": false,
214 "role": "primary",
215 "source_ids": [
216 "SW-S11"
217 ],
218 "study_designs": [
219 "cohort",
220 "case_control",
221 "cross_sectional",
222 "observational"
223 ],
224 "version": "2007"
225 },
226 {
227 "conditions": {},
228 "coverage_topics": [
229 {
230 "id": "participants-and-design",
231 "label": "Participant selection, setting, design, and data collection"
232 },
233 {
234 "id": "index-test-and-reference-standard",
235 "label": "Index test, reference standard, thresholds, and blinding"
236 },
237 {
238 "id": "analysis-and-indeterminate-results",
239 "label": "Accuracy estimates, uncertainty, missing, and indeterminate results"
240 },
241 {
242 "id": "flow-and-applicability",
243 "label": "Participant flow, timing, adverse events, and applicability"
244 }
245 ],
246 "id": "stard-2015",
247 "name": "STARD 2015",
248 "official_url": "https://resources.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/stard",
249 "protocol": false,
250 "role": "primary",
251 "source_ids": [
252 "SW-S12"
253 ],
254 "study_designs": [
255 "diagnostic_accuracy"
256 ],
257 "version": "2015"
258 },
259 {
260 "conditions": {
261 "ai": true
262 },
263 "coverage_topics": [
264 {
265 "id": "dataset-and-model-provenance",
266 "label": "Dataset provenance, model version, training status, and access"
267 },
268 {
269 "id": "ai-test-conduct",
270 "label": "AI index-test execution, human interaction, thresholds, and reference standard"
271 },
272 {
273 "id": "fairness-failures-and-generalizability",
274 "label": "Subgroups, fairness, failure cases, uncertainty, and generalizability"
275 }
276 ],
277 "id": "stard-ai-2025",
278 "name": "STARD-AI",
279 "official_url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-025-03953-8",
280 "protocol": false,
281 "role": "extension",
282 "source_ids": [
283 "SW-S13"
284 ],
285 "study_designs": [
286 "diagnostic_accuracy"
287 ],
288 "version": "2025"
289 },
290 {
291 "conditions": {},
292 "coverage_topics": [
293 {
294 "id": "data-source-and-participants",
295 "label": "Data source, participants, setting, and outcome definition"
296 },
297 {
298 "id": "predictors-and-sample-size",
299 "label": "Predictors, sample size, missing data, and class balance"
300 },
301 {
302 "id": "model-development-and-validation",
303 "label": "Model development, tuning, validation, and updating"
304 },
305 {
306 "id": "performance-and-clinical-utility",
307 "label": "Performance, uncertainty, calibration, discrimination, and utility"
308 },
309 {
310 "id": "fairness-transparency-and-access",
311 "label": "Subgroups, fairness, interpretability, model access, data, and code"
312 }
313 ],
314 "id": "tripod-ai-2024",
315 "name": "TRIPOD+AI",
316 "official_url": "https://www.tripod-statement.org/",
317 "protocol": false,
318 "role": "primary",
319 "source_ids": [
320 "SW-S14"
321 ],
322 "study_designs": [
323 "prediction_model",
324 "diagnostic_prediction_model",
325 "prognostic_prediction_model"
326 ],
327 "version": "2024"
328 },
329 {
330 "conditions": {
331 "llm": true
332 },
333 "coverage_topics": [
334 {
335 "id": "llm-task-and-version",
336 "label": "Task definition, model identity, version, prompts, and updates"
337 },
338 {
339 "id": "evaluation-and-human-oversight",
340 "label": "Evaluation design, human oversight, comparators, and failure analysis"
341 },
342 {
343 "id": "llm-safety-and-reproducibility",
344 "label": "Privacy, bias, safety, reproducibility, and access constraints"
345 }
346 ],
347 "id": "tripod-llm-2025",
348 "name": "TRIPOD-LLM",
349 "official_url": "https://www.tripod-statement.org/",
350 "protocol": false,
351 "role": "extension",
352 "source_ids": [
353 "SW-S14"
354 ],
355 "study_designs": [
356 "prediction_model",
357 "diagnostic_prediction_model",
358 "prognostic_prediction_model"
359 ],
360 "version": "2025"
361 },
362 {
363 "conditions": {},
364 "coverage_topics": [
365 {
366 "id": "patient-information-and-consent",
367 "label": "De-identified patient information, consent, and perspective"
368 },
369 {
370 "id": "timeline-and-clinical-findings",
371 "label": "Timeline, clinical findings, diagnostic assessment, and reasoning"
372 },
373 {
374 "id": "intervention-follow-up-and-outcomes",
375 "label": "Interventions, follow-up, outcomes, adverse events, and adherence"
376 },
377 {
378 "id": "discussion-and-limitations",
379 "label": "Context, strengths, limitations, and cautious take-away lessons"
380 }
381 ],
382 "id": "care-2013",
383 "name": "CARE",
384 "official_url": "https://www.care-statement.org/checklist",
385 "protocol": false,
386 "role": "primary",
387 "source_ids": [
388 "SW-S15"
389 ],
390 "study_designs": [
391 "case_report"
392 ],
393 "version": "2013"
394 },
395 {
396 "conditions": {},
397 "coverage_topics": [
398 {
399 "id": "design-sample-size-and-criteria",
400 "label": "Study design, experimental unit, sample size, and inclusion or exclusion"
401 },
402 {
403 "id": "randomization-blinding-and-outcomes",
404 "label": "Randomization, blinding, outcomes, and statistical methods"
405 },
406 {
407 "id": "animals-procedures-and-welfare",
408 "label": "Animal details, procedures, housing, welfare, and adverse events"
409 },
410 {
411 "id": "ethics-interpretation-and-data",
412 "label": "Ethics, limitations, interpretation, protocol, data, and conflicts"
413 }
414 ],
415 "id": "arrive-2.0-2020",
416 "name": "ARRIVE 2.0",
417 "official_url": "https://arriveguidelines.org/arrive-guidelines",
418 "protocol": false,
419 "role": "primary",
420 "source_ids": [
421 "SW-S16"
422 ],
423 "study_designs": [
424 "animal_in_vivo"
425 ],
426 "version": "2.0 (2020)"
427 },
428 {
429 "conditions": {},
430 "coverage_topics": [
431 {
432 "id": "problem-context-and-rationale",
433 "label": "Local problem, available knowledge, context, rationale, and aims"
434 },
435 {
436 "id": "intervention-study-and-measures",
437 "label": "Intervention, study of the intervention, measures, and analysis"
438 },
439 {
440 "id": "ethics-results-and-variation",
441 "label": "Ethical considerations, evolution, outcomes, and variation over time"
442 },
443 {
444 "id": "interpretation-limitations-and-sustainability",
445 "label": "Interpretation, limitations, sustainability, spread, and funding"
446 }
447 ],
448 "id": "squire-2.0-2015",
449 "name": "SQUIRE 2.0",
450 "official_url": "https://www.squire-statement.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=page.viewPage&pageID=471&nodeID=1",
451 "protocol": false,
452 "role": "primary",
453 "source_ids": [
454 "SW-S17"
455 ],
456 "study_designs": [
457 "quality_improvement"
458 ],
459 "version": "2.0 (2015)"
460 },
461 {
462 "conditions": {},
463 "coverage_topics": [
464 {
465 "id": "population-setting-perspective",
466 "label": "Population, setting, perspective, comparators, and time horizon"
467 },
468 {
469 "id": "effects-costs-and-currency",
470 "label": "Health outcomes, resources, costs, currency, and price date"
471 },
472 {
473 "id": "model-assumptions-and-uncertainty",
474 "label": "Model, assumptions, analysis plan, uncertainty, and distributional effects"
475 },
476 {
477 "id": "engagement-results-and-conflicts",
478 "label": "Stakeholder engagement, results, limitations, funding, and conflicts"
479 }
480 ],
481 "id": "cheers-2022",
482 "name": "CHEERS 2022",
483 "official_url": "https://www.ispor.org/heor-resources/good-practices/article/consolidated-health-economic-evaluation-reporting-standards-2022-cheers-2022-statement-updated-reporting-guidance-for-health-economic-evaluations",
484 "protocol": false,
485 "role": "primary",
486 "source_ids": [
487 "SW-S18"
488 ],
489 "study_designs": [
490 "health_economic_evaluation"
491 ],
492 "version": "2022"
493 },
494 {
495 "conditions": {},
496 "coverage_topics": [
497 {
498 "id": "approach-context-and-researchers",
499 "label": "Qualitative approach, context, researcher characteristics, and reflexivity"
500 },
501 {
502 "id": "sampling-ethics-and-data-collection",
503 "label": "Sampling, ethics, consent, data collection, and instruments"
504 },
505 {
506 "id": "analysis-trustworthiness-and-findings",
507 "label": "Analysis, trustworthiness, findings, quotations, and links to data"
508 },
509 {
510 "id": "limitations-implications-and-funding",
511 "label": "Limitations, implications, conflicts, and funding"
512 }
513 ],
514 "id": "srqr-2014",
515 "name": "SRQR",
516 "official_url": "https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/srqr/",
517 "protocol": false,
518 "role": "primary",
519 "source_ids": [
520 "SW-S33"
521 ],
522 "study_designs": [
523 "qualitative"
524 ],
525 "version": "2014"
526 }
527 ],
528 "schema_version": "1.0"
529}