Skills › Scientific Agent Skills › peer-review › reporting_guidelines.json
reporting_guidelines.json
489 lines · skills/peer-review/assets/reporting_guidelines.json at 5f2bc03
1{
2 "schema_version": "2.0",
3 "reviewed_on": "2026-10-01",
4 "notice": "This catalog supports reporting-guideline selection only. Verify the official source, applicable extensions, and target venue policy. Checklist coverage is not a quality or merit score.",
5 "guidelines": [
6 {
7 "id": "ARRIVE-2.0",
8 "name": "ARRIVE",
9 "version": "2.0 (2020)",
10 "status": "current",
11 "category": "reporting_guideline",
12 "study_types": [
13 "animal_in_vivo"
14 ],
15 "report_kinds": [
16 "results"
17 ],
18 "required_features": [],
19 "domains": [
20 "all"
21 ],
22 "main_item_count": 21,
23 "url": "https://arriveguidelines.org/arrive-guidelines",
24 "notes": "Use Essential 10 and Recommended Set; reporting supports appraisal but does not by itself establish rigor."
25 },
26 {
27 "id": "CARE-2013",
28 "name": "CARE",
29 "version": "2013 checklist; 2017 explanation",
30 "status": "current",
31 "category": "reporting_guideline",
32 "study_types": [
33 "case_report"
34 ],
35 "report_kinds": [
36 "results"
37 ],
38 "required_features": [],
39 "domains": [
40 "health"
41 ],
42 "main_item_count": 13,
43 "url": "https://www.care-statement.org/checklist",
44 "notes": "Confirm informed consent and privacy requirements with the target venue and applicable law."
45 },
46 {
47 "id": "CHEERS-2022",
48 "name": "CHEERS",
49 "version": "2022",
50 "status": "current",
51 "category": "reporting_guideline",
52 "study_types": [
53 "economic_evaluation"
54 ],
55 "report_kinds": [
56 "results"
57 ],
58 "required_features": [],
59 "domains": [
60 "health"
61 ],
62 "main_item_count": 28,
63 "url": "https://www.ispor.org/heor-resources/good-practices/cheers",
64 "notes": "For economic evaluations of health interventions; use the explanation and elaboration."
65 },
66 {
67 "id": "CONSORT-2025",
68 "name": "CONSORT",
69 "version": "2025",
70 "status": "current",
71 "category": "reporting_guideline",
72 "study_types": [
73 "randomized_trial"
74 ],
75 "report_kinds": [
76 "results"
77 ],
78 "required_features": [],
79 "domains": [
80 "health",
81 "all"
82 ],
83 "main_item_count": 30,
84 "url": "https://www.consort-spirit.org/",
85 "notes": "Supersedes CONSORT 2010. Check design-specific extensions; CONSORT is not a quality assessment instrument."
86 },
87 {
88 "id": "CONSORT-AI-2020",
89 "name": "CONSORT-AI",
90 "version": "2020 extension",
91 "status": "current",
92 "category": "reporting_guideline",
93 "study_types": [
94 "randomized_trial"
95 ],
96 "report_kinds": [
97 "results"
98 ],
99 "required_features": [
100 "ai_intervention"
101 ],
102 "domains": [
103 "health"
104 ],
105 "main_item_count": null,
106 "url": "https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/consort-artificial-intelligence/",
107 "notes": "Use the 2020 extension alongside CONSORT 2025 for AI intervention trials. It was written against CONSORT 2010; map items by meaning, not inherited item numbers, and check current extension guidance."
108 },
109 {
110 "id": "COREQ-2007",
111 "name": "COREQ",
112 "version": "2007",
113 "status": "current",
114 "category": "reporting_guideline",
115 "study_types": [
116 "qualitative_interview",
117 "qualitative_focus_group"
118 ],
119 "report_kinds": [
120 "results"
121 ],
122 "required_features": [],
123 "domains": [
124 "health"
125 ],
126 "main_item_count": 32,
127 "url": "https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/coreq/",
128 "notes": "For interviews and focus groups; consider SRQR for broader qualitative study designs."
129 },
130 {
131 "id": "PRISMA-2020",
132 "name": "PRISMA",
133 "version": "2020 (published 2021)",
134 "status": "current",
135 "category": "reporting_guideline",
136 "study_types": [
137 "systematic_review"
138 ],
139 "report_kinds": [
140 "results"
141 ],
142 "required_features": [],
143 "domains": [
144 "all"
145 ],
146 "main_item_count": 27,
147 "url": "https://www.prisma-statement.org/prisma-2020",
148 "notes": "Use the relevant extension for scoping, diagnostic, individual-participant-data, or other review types. PRISMA does not assess methodological quality."
149 },
150 {
151 "id": "PRISMA-P-2015",
152 "name": "PRISMA-P",
153 "version": "2015",
154 "status": "current",
155 "category": "reporting_guideline",
156 "study_types": [
157 "systematic_review"
158 ],
159 "report_kinds": [
160 "protocol"
161 ],
162 "required_features": [],
163 "domains": [
164 "all"
165 ],
166 "main_item_count": null,
167 "url": "https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/prisma-protocols/",
168 "notes": "Use for systematic review protocols rather than completed review reports."
169 },
170 {
171 "id": "SPIRIT-2025",
172 "name": "SPIRIT",
173 "version": "2025",
174 "status": "current",
175 "category": "reporting_guideline",
176 "study_types": [
177 "randomized_trial"
178 ],
179 "report_kinds": [
180 "protocol"
181 ],
182 "required_features": [],
183 "domains": [
184 "health",
185 "all"
186 ],
187 "main_item_count": 34,
188 "url": "https://www.consort-spirit.org/",
189 "notes": "Supersedes SPIRIT 2013. Compare protocol, registry, statistical analysis plan, amendments, and final report for consistency."
190 },
191 {
192 "id": "SPIRIT-AI-2020",
193 "name": "SPIRIT-AI",
194 "version": "2020 extension",
195 "status": "current",
196 "category": "reporting_guideline",
197 "study_types": [
198 "randomized_trial"
199 ],
200 "report_kinds": [
201 "protocol"
202 ],
203 "required_features": [
204 "ai_intervention"
205 ],
206 "domains": [
207 "health"
208 ],
209 "main_item_count": null,
210 "url": "https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/spirit-artificial-intelligence/",
211 "notes": "Use the 2020 AI-intervention extension alongside SPIRIT 2025. It was written against SPIRIT 2013; map items by meaning, not inherited item numbers, and check current extension guidance."
212 },
213 {
214 "id": "SQUIRE-2.0",
215 "name": "SQUIRE",
216 "version": "2.0 (2015)",
217 "status": "current",
218 "category": "reporting_guideline",
219 "study_types": [
220 "quality_improvement"
221 ],
222 "report_kinds": [
223 "results"
224 ],
225 "required_features": [],
226 "domains": [
227 "health"
228 ],
229 "main_item_count": 18,
230 "url": "https://www.squire-statement.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=page.viewPage&pageID=471&nodeID=1",
231 "notes": "For system-level work to improve healthcare; not every element is applicable to every manuscript."
232 },
233 {
234 "id": "SRQR-2014",
235 "name": "SRQR",
236 "version": "2014",
237 "status": "current",
238 "category": "reporting_guideline",
239 "study_types": [
240 "qualitative_study"
241 ],
242 "report_kinds": [
243 "results"
244 ],
245 "required_features": [],
246 "domains": [
247 "health"
248 ],
249 "main_item_count": 21,
250 "url": "https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/srqr",
251 "notes": "Broad qualitative reporting standard; choose COREQ when interviews or focus groups are the primary methods."
252 },
253 {
254 "id": "STARD-2015",
255 "name": "STARD",
256 "version": "2015",
257 "status": "current",
258 "category": "reporting_guideline",
259 "study_types": [
260 "diagnostic_accuracy"
261 ],
262 "report_kinds": [
263 "results"
264 ],
265 "required_features": [],
266 "domains": [
267 "health"
268 ],
269 "main_item_count": 30,
270 "url": "https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/stard/",
271 "notes": "For diagnostic accuracy studies. Use a separate risk-of-bias tool for design/conduct appraisal."
272 },
273 {
274 "id": "STARD-AI-2025",
275 "name": "STARD-AI",
276 "version": "2025",
277 "status": "current",
278 "category": "reporting_guideline",
279 "study_types": [
280 "diagnostic_accuracy"
281 ],
282 "report_kinds": [
283 "results"
284 ],
285 "required_features": [
286 "ai_based"
287 ],
288 "domains": [
289 "health"
290 ],
291 "main_item_count": 40,
292 "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-025-03953-8",
293 "notes": "Use for AI-centered diagnostic accuracy studies and alongside the applicable base and modality guidance."
294 },
295 {
296 "id": "STROBE-2007",
297 "name": "STROBE",
298 "version": "2007",
299 "status": "current",
300 "category": "reporting_guideline",
301 "study_types": [
302 "observational_study",
303 "cohort_study",
304 "case_control_study",
305 "cross_sectional_study"
306 ],
307 "report_kinds": [
308 "results"
309 ],
310 "required_features": [],
311 "domains": [
312 "health"
313 ],
314 "main_item_count": 22,
315 "url": "https://www.strobe-statement.org/",
316 "notes": "Select the design-specific checklist and applicable extensions such as RECORD, STREGA, or STROBE-MR."
317 },
318 {
319 "id": "TRIPOD-AI-2024",
320 "name": "TRIPOD+AI",
321 "version": "2024",
322 "status": "current",
323 "category": "reporting_guideline",
324 "study_types": [
325 "prediction_model"
326 ],
327 "report_kinds": [
328 "results"
329 ],
330 "required_features": [],
331 "domains": [
332 "health"
333 ],
334 "main_item_count": 27,
335 "url": "https://www.tripod-statement.org/",
336 "notes": "Replaces TRIPOD 2015 and applies to regression or machine-learning model development and performance evaluation."
337 },
338 {
339 "id": "TRIPOD-LLM-2025",
340 "name": "TRIPOD-LLM",
341 "version": "2025",
342 "status": "current",
343 "category": "reporting_guideline",
344 "study_types": [
345 "llm_study",
346 "prediction_model"
347 ],
348 "report_kinds": [
349 "results"
350 ],
351 "required_features": [
352 "large_language_model"
353 ],
354 "domains": [
355 "health"
356 ],
357 "main_item_count": 19,
358 "url": "https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/the-tripod-llm-reporting-guideline-for-studies-using-large-language-models/",
359 "notes": "For biomedical/healthcare studies developing, tuning, prompt engineering, or evaluating LLMs, including non-prediction tasks. Use TRIPOD+AI additionally when prediction-model reporting applies; consult the separate abstract checklist for abstracts."
360 },
361 {
362 "id": "MIAME-2001",
363 "name": "MIAME",
364 "version": "2001 content standard; repository guidance current",
365 "status": "legacy_current_qualified",
366 "category": "domain_metadata_standard",
367 "study_types": [
368 "microarray"
369 ],
370 "report_kinds": [
371 "results",
372 "data_release"
373 ],
374 "required_features": [],
375 "domains": [
376 "functional_genomics"
377 ],
378 "main_item_count": null,
379 "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/info/MIAME.html",
380 "notes": "GEO guidance supports MIAME; verify current repository submission fields and required data content."
381 },
382 {
383 "id": "MIAPE-CURRENT",
384 "name": "MIAPE",
385 "version": "modular released components",
386 "status": "legacy_current_qualified",
387 "category": "domain_metadata_standard",
388 "study_types": [
389 "proteomics"
390 ],
391 "report_kinds": [
392 "results",
393 "data_release"
394 ],
395 "required_features": [],
396 "domains": [
397 "proteomics"
398 ],
399 "main_item_count": null,
400 "url": "https://www.psidev.info/miape",
401 "notes": "Select the current PSI component for the actual workflow; MIAPE is modular, not one universal checklist."
402 },
403 {
404 "id": "MIAPPE-1.2",
405 "name": "MIAPPE",
406 "version": "1.2 (October 2024)",
407 "status": "current",
408 "category": "domain_metadata_standard",
409 "study_types": [
410 "plant_phenotyping"
411 ],
412 "report_kinds": [
413 "results",
414 "data_release"
415 ],
416 "required_features": [],
417 "domains": [
418 "plant_science"
419 ],
420 "main_item_count": null,
421 "url": "https://www.miappe.org/releases",
422 "notes": "Use version 1.2; version 2.0 was still under early development at the review date."
423 },
424 {
425 "id": "MIFlowCyt-1.0",
426 "name": "MIFlowCyt",
427 "version": "1.0; ISAC recommendation current",
428 "status": "legacy_current_qualified",
429 "category": "domain_metadata_standard",
430 "study_types": [
431 "flow_cytometry"
432 ],
433 "report_kinds": [
434 "results",
435 "data_release"
436 ],
437 "required_features": [],
438 "domains": [
439 "cytometry"
440 ],
441 "main_item_count": null,
442 "url": "https://isac-net.org/miflowcyt-2/",
443 "notes": "Retained as an active ISAC recommendation; also verify FCS, gating, and repository requirements."
444 },
445 {
446 "id": "MINSEQE-CURRENT",
447 "name": "MINSEQE",
448 "version": "repository guidance current",
449 "status": "legacy_current_qualified",
450 "category": "domain_metadata_standard",
451 "study_types": [
452 "high_throughput_sequencing"
453 ],
454 "report_kinds": [
455 "results",
456 "data_release"
457 ],
458 "required_features": [],
459 "domains": [
460 "functional_genomics"
461 ],
462 "main_item_count": null,
463 "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/info/MIAME.html",
464 "notes": "GEO guidance supports MINSEQE for high-throughput functional genomics experiments; verify platform-specific repository requirements."
465 },
466 {
467 "id": "MIxS-CURRENT",
468 "name": "MIxS",
469 "version": "current GSC release",
470 "status": "current",
471 "category": "domain_metadata_standard",
472 "study_types": [
473 "genome_sequence",
474 "metagenome_sequence"
475 ],
476 "report_kinds": [
477 "results",
478 "data_release"
479 ],
480 "required_features": [],
481 "domains": [
482 "genomics"
483 ],
484 "main_item_count": null,
485 "url": "https://www.gensc.org/pages/standards-intro.html",
486 "notes": "Use MIxS as the current umbrella; MIGS and MIMS are legacy checklists within the MIxS framework."
487 }
488 ]
489}