Skills › Scientific Agent Skills › clinical-decision-support › evidence_profile_template.json
evidence_profile_template.json
139 lines · skills/clinical-decision-support/assets/evidence_profile_template.json at 5f2bc03
1{
2 "schema_version": "1.0",
3 "profile_id": "REPLACE_WITH_PROFILE_ID",
4 "title": "Human-Judged GRADE Evidence Profile",
5 "data_level": "published_aggregate_evidence",
6 "human_judgments_required": true,
7 "auto_grade": false,
8 "intended_use": "Research evidence synthesis and panel documentation only.",
9 "prohibited_uses": [
10 "No automatic evidence grade or recommendation strength.",
11 "No patient-specific diagnosis, treatment recommendation, dosing, triage, alarm, or autonomous decision.",
12 "No claim of clinical, regulatory, legal, or HIPAA compliance."
13 ],
14 "limitations": [
15 "No certainty judgment is inferred from text or study design.",
16 "Certainty is outcome-specific.",
17 "Recommendation development requires a separate human Evidence-to-Decision process."
18 ],
19 "human_review": {
20 "required": true,
21 "roles": [
22 "systematic-review methodologist",
23 "domain expert",
24 "GRADE panel chair"
25 ],
26 "completed": false
27 },
28 "governance": {
29 "version": "0.1-draft",
30 "owner": "REPLACE_WITH_EVIDENCE_PROFILE_OWNER_ROLE",
31 "change_summary": "Initial unresolved template.",
32 "auditability": "Retain searches, selection decisions, source versions, domain judgments, disagreements, and approvals.",
33 "update_plan": "Define surveillance, update triggers, supersession, and retirement."
34 },
35 "question": {
36 "population": "REPLACE_WITH_DEFINED_POPULATION",
37 "intervention_or_exposure": "REPLACE_WITH_INTERVENTION_OR_EXPOSURE",
38 "comparator": "REPLACE_WITH_COMPARATOR",
39 "setting": "REPLACE_WITH_SETTING",
40 "outcomes": [
41 "REPLACE_WITH_IMPORTANT_OUTCOME_AND_TIME_HORIZON"
42 ]
43 },
44 "sources": [
45 {
46 "id": "SRC-001",
47 "citation": "REPLACE_WITH_FULL_CITATION",
48 "url": "REPLACE_WITH_CANONICAL_URL",
49 "accessed": "YYYY-MM-DD"
50 }
51 ],
52 "outcomes": [
53 {
54 "name": "REPLACE_WITH_OUTCOME",
55 "importance": "critical",
56 "effect_measure": "REPLACE_WITH_EFFECT_MEASURE",
57 "effect_estimate": "REPLACE_WITH_ABSOLUTE_AND_RELATIVE_EFFECTS",
58 "uncertainty_interval": "REPLACE_WITH_INTERVAL",
59 "participants": "REPLACE_WITH_NUMBER_AND_ANALYSIS_POPULATION",
60 "studies": "REPLACE_WITH_NUMBER_AND_DESIGNS",
61 "time_horizon": "REPLACE_WITH_TIME_HORIZON",
62 "domains": {
63 "risk_of_bias": {
64 "judgment": "unassessed",
65 "rationale": "REQUIRES_HUMAN_JUDGMENT",
66 "reviewer_role": "REPLACE_WITH_REVIEWER_ROLE",
67 "source_ids": [
68 "SRC-001"
69 ]
70 },
71 "inconsistency": {
72 "judgment": "unassessed",
73 "rationale": "REQUIRES_HUMAN_JUDGMENT",
74 "reviewer_role": "REPLACE_WITH_REVIEWER_ROLE",
75 "source_ids": [
76 "SRC-001"
77 ]
78 },
79 "indirectness": {
80 "judgment": "unassessed",
81 "rationale": "REQUIRES_HUMAN_JUDGMENT",
82 "reviewer_role": "REPLACE_WITH_REVIEWER_ROLE",
83 "source_ids": [
84 "SRC-001"
85 ]
86 },
87 "imprecision": {
88 "judgment": "unassessed",
89 "rationale": "REQUIRES_HUMAN_JUDGMENT",
90 "reviewer_role": "REPLACE_WITH_REVIEWER_ROLE",
91 "source_ids": [
92 "SRC-001"
93 ]
94 },
95 "publication_bias": {
96 "judgment": "unassessed",
97 "rationale": "REQUIRES_HUMAN_JUDGMENT",
98 "reviewer_role": "REPLACE_WITH_REVIEWER_ROLE",
99 "source_ids": [
100 "SRC-001"
101 ]
102 }
103 },
104 "upgrading": {
105 "large_effect": {
106 "judgment": "unassessed",
107 "rationale": "REQUIRES_HUMAN_JUDGMENT",
108 "source_ids": []
109 },
110 "dose_response": {
111 "judgment": "unassessed",
112 "rationale": "REQUIRES_HUMAN_JUDGMENT",
113 "source_ids": []
114 },
115 "residual_confounding": {
116 "judgment": "unassessed",
117 "rationale": "REQUIRES_HUMAN_JUDGMENT",
118 "source_ids": []
119 }
120 },
121 "certainty": {
122 "human_judgment": false,
123 "level": "unassessed",
124 "rationale": "REQUIRES_HUMAN_PANEL_JUDGMENT",
125 "reviewer_role": "REPLACE_WITH_PANEL_ROLE",
126 "judgment_date": "YYYY-MM-DD",
127 "source_ids": [
128 "SRC-001"
129 ]
130 }
131 }
132 ],
133 "profile_review": {
134 "prepared_by_role": "REPLACE_WITH_ROLE",
135 "reviewed_by_role": "REPLACE_WITH_ROLE",
136 "review_date": "YYYY-MM-DD",
137 "completed": false
138 }
139}