Skills › Scientific Agent Skills › scholar-evaluation › evaluation_template.json
evaluation_template.json
50 lines · skills/scholar-evaluation/assets/evaluation_template.json at 5f2bc03
1{
2 "schema_version": "2.0",
3 "evaluation_id": "EVALUATION-SYNTHETIC-001",
4 "rubric_id": "RUBRIC-SYNTHETIC-001",
5 "work_id": "WORK-SYNTHETIC-001",
6 "data_classification": "synthetic",
7 "purpose": "developmental_review_of_scholarly_work",
8 "ratings": [
9 {
10 "criterion_id": "question_scope",
11 "status": "missing",
12 "score": null,
13 "uncertainty": null,
14 "evidence_ids": [],
15 "rationale_ref": "LOCAL-MISSING-RATIONALE-QUESTION"
16 },
17 {
18 "criterion_id": "literature_contribution",
19 "status": "missing",
20 "score": null,
21 "uncertainty": null,
22 "evidence_ids": [],
23 "rationale_ref": "LOCAL-MISSING-RATIONALE-LITERATURE"
24 },
25 {
26 "criterion_id": "method_design",
27 "status": "missing",
28 "score": null,
29 "uncertainty": null,
30 "evidence_ids": [],
31 "rationale_ref": "LOCAL-MISSING-RATIONALE-METHOD"
32 },
33 {
34 "criterion_id": "analysis_claims",
35 "status": "missing",
36 "score": null,
37 "uncertainty": null,
38 "evidence_ids": [],
39 "rationale_ref": "LOCAL-MISSING-RATIONALE-ANALYSIS"
40 },
41 {
42 "criterion_id": "transparency_integrity",
43 "status": "missing",
44 "score": null,
45 "uncertainty": null,
46 "evidence_ids": [],
47 "rationale_ref": "LOCAL-MISSING-RATIONALE-TRANSPARENCY"
48 }
49 ]
50}